And the winners are in! Discover this year's 50 best beauty products—all tested by real women and starting at just $3. Plus: Use This Handy Shopping Directory to Find the Products in This List at the Lowest Prices! »
Best Eye Shadow
Almay Shadow Softies by Intense i-Color (shown in Lilac and Creme Brulee) $5; at mass retailers
Why it won: The cream-to-powder shadows don't crease or smudge. Plus, "the shades are super wearable," one tester said.